22 Favorite Pie Recipes For Any Occasion

Pie! There’s almost nothing else you need to say about the classic dessert. It comes in all kinds of flavors and textures, from fruit pies to cream pies to toasted meringue topped beauties. I love all the flavors and varieties. You can find a pie for any occasion, all year long, and this list of pies includes all of my favorite recipes.

Want more pie content? Check out these guides:

And if you came across this post around Thanksgiving and are looking for something a little different this year, try my 10 desserts that go beyond pie!

Three basic components (meringue pie crust, vanilla pastry cream and sour cherry sauce) make up this easy but impressive cherry angel pie!
Get the recipe
What makes a peach pie even better? Adding candied bacon. The salty sweet combination of this pie is treat that can be eaten all year round.
Get the recipe
This pear pie with caramel is a perfect fall or winter treat. It looks stunning, but you'll be surprised just how easy it is to put together. Simply make a few components, then assemble and bake.
Get the recipe
I stock my freezer with these delicious strawberry hand pies for a fast and easy treat. The pies are sweet and just a little tart, making them perfect little homemade breakfast pastries
Get the recipe
If you’ve seen my show on Magnolia Network, you will be familiar with this beauty from the pie master, Rachel Swan. Anyone lucky enough to be in Minneapolis should try her pie at Pie & Mighty, but if you don’t you can try my version, with lime curd and berries.
Get the recipe
Would you ever guess just by looking at this chocolate pecan pie that it's dairy free? I swapped plant butter for regular dairy butter and it worked beautifully! No one I served this to guessed it was made without dairy butter!
Get the recipe
This peanut butter pie recipe is oh-so delicious. With a graham cracker crust, a smooth peanut butter filling made with cream cheese, a layer of chocolate ganache, and a whipped cream and candied peanut topping, this dessert is deluxe and irresistible. Be sure to chill this pie for two hours or overnight before serving.
Get the recipe
This is a version of the Perfect Apple Pie recipe, but with a lacy whole wheat crust thanks to an embossed rolling pin.
Get the recipe
Key Lime Pie is what I would make if stuck on a desert island. It satisfies my craving for sweet, creamy and tart. The perfect dessert!
Get the recipe
Purple Sweet Potato Pie with a mound of an Italian meringue inspired by Esther Williams (anyone younger than me will have to google her).
Get the recipe
This pie from Shauna Sever's book, Midwest Made, is all about the deep chocolate flavor. Be sure to use a high quality, bitter chocolate (70-75% cacao) or the pie can get very sweet, FAST! In her book the pie is topped with a homemade Cool Whip, which is 100% in keeping with the traditional pie. I left the cream unstabilized and unsweetened, because I like the contrast of the sweet filling to the clean, rich cream on top, you choose which way to go.
Get the recipe
It's funny how rather retro American desserts, like the Banana Cream Pie bring back memories of grandmothers and childhoods. I am happy to report this version, inspired by Sarabeth's Bakery, does not disappoint. You have to make one to see how beautifully it cuts and how fantastic it tastes.
Get the recipe
This pie is all the things I love in a pumpkin pie and more. The pumpkin filling is not too sweet, because of the tang of buttermilk and it's combined with a crunchy streusel made with pepitas and buckwheat. From Sister Pie: The Recipes and Stories of a Big-Hearted Bakery in Detroit by Lisa Ludwinski
Get the recipe
The Perfect Apple Pie is from Cenk Sönmezsoy's The Artful Baker, and trust me, I don't hand out that description without great consideration. The pie is jammed packed with super thin slices of apples, so that it is dense. If you take the time to stack them, you'll see the clean lines of apple when you cut into it. This pie takes a little longer to make, but the results are worth every second.
Get the recipe
There is nothing more beautiful than a perfectly ripe, juicy, smooth, sweet peach, so don't fuss it all up with too much extra stuff. This perfect peach pie with lattice crust is really just peaches, a touch of booze (which is optional) and some raw sugar.
Get the recipe
I love strawberries, but they are a bit too sweet and jammy on their own in a pie. The marriage of rhubarb and strawberries is perfection, because sometimes opposites attract.
Get the recipe
This Lemon Honey-Meringue Pie is very easy to make, but there are some steps that will take your pie from a weepy mess to a magnificent mile-high showpiece.
Get the recipe
To make the pie extra special, roast your own pumpkin. I promise it is it worth it, and not nearly as hard as it sounds. Canned is fine too, and no matter how you get your pumpkin flavor, the resulting combination of flavors in this pie is a must for your dessert table.
Get the recipe
I love pie, all pies, but this blueberry pie stands above the rest. When wild blueberries are baked up in a pie shell, with just a bit of lemon, some sugar and pats of butter, I could eat the whole thing.
Get the recipe
The key to success with this sweet, but not too sweet, pie is to use sour cherries. Combined with just enough sugar and a pinch of black pepper, the sour cherries add a tart balance that goes perfectly with the rich, buttery crust.
Get the recipe
A classic rhubarb pie recipe with lattice crust. Cherries (or raspberries!) are added for sweetness.
Get the recipe
This white peach and raspberry pie is pure summer. I used fresh fruit from the farmers' market, which is the only way to go.
Get the recipe

Share this post

2 thoughts to “22 Favorite Pie Recipes For Any Occasion”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *