Holiday Sugar Cookies

Holiday Sugar Cookie House | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

This is an updated post from one of my very first blogging efforts back in 2007. The recipe is wonderful, but my photos were a bit rough back then. You can see them at the end of the post, I kept them, because they are sentimental. This Holiday Sugar Cookies recipe is perfect for simple cut out cookies and for building a more intricate house. I live in a big house that makes me think of a wedding cake or confection. I have been meaning to create it out of cookies since I moved in and I finally did it. I think it will become an annual tradition and I imagine I will get more and more detailed with every try. This one was so much fun. I am lucky to have the original blueprints for the house, so it made it easier to trace the outline of the house, but I just approximated where I to, since it didn’t have to be built to stand for very long! 😉

2007 Post: My aunt Kristin is a great collector of recipes. She sends me packages of them, often! The recipes come from magazines, books, cooking shows, gourmet grocery stores and various people she meets. They are far too numerous to try all of them, but I use them as a constant source of inspiration. This past week, just in time for Christmas she sent me a sugar cookie recipe by Dorie Greenspan she had clipped from Bon Appetit and a set of snow flake cookie cutters. I am always searching for the perfect sugar cookie. I’m not sure yet if this is THE ONE, but it is really great. The flavor is not too sweet, slightly lemony (because I added the lemon zest) and the texture is crisp but not at all tough.

I decorated the cookies and house with royal Icing made with lemon juice, which is tasty, quite stunning and strong enough to hold up as the glue for the house. I’ll admit that I love the fussy work of intricate decorations on sugar cookies. It is the closest I will come to ever using my BFA from college. If you don’t share my enthusiasm for precision piping then just sprinkle them with colored sugar like my boys did and they are delicious and festive!

Obviously this recipe and technique are great for Valentines Day, Easter and any other holiday or special occasion when you celebrate with sweets! Which means every day…

Holiday Sugar Cookie House | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

Holiday Sugar Cookies

Dorie Greenspan’s Sugar Cookies (Bon Appetit December 2007)

10 tablespoons (1 1/4 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature

1/2 cup (115g) sugar

1 large egg

1 1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract (Homemade)

1 teaspoon lemon zest (optional)

2 cups (280g) all-purpose flour

1/4 teaspoon salt

1/4 teaspoon baking powder (not original to Dorie’s recipe, but I like the bit of lift it gives the cookies)

Cream together the butter, sugar and salt in a mixer fitter with the paddle attachment, until pale and fluffy, about 2 minutes. Add egg, beat until well blended, about 1 minute, then add vanilla and lemon. Scrape down the sides of the bowl. Add flour, salt and baking powder, mix on a low speed until just combined. Gather dough into a ball, divide in half. Form each half into a flattened disk and wrap in plastic, chill for at least 4 hours. (I only chilled mine for 2 hours and it seemed to roll out and bake beautifully) It can be made up to 3 days ahead or freeze for later.

Preheat oven to 325°F. (Dorie has you bake at 350°F, but since I was baking really large cookies, I wanted to lower the heat so they would bake without taking on too much color.) Line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper.

Working with one disk at a time, Dorie has you roll out dough between two sheets of wax paper to 1/8″ thin. (I didn’t have any so I rolled mine out on a lightly floured counter and it worked just great.)

Using decorative cookie cutters, cut out cookies and transfer to a cookie sheet, spacing 1 inch apart. Gather any scraps, roll them out until all the dough is used. If not using icing then decorated with sprinkles before baking.

Bake one sheet at a time until cookies are firm and golden around the edges, about 10 minutes for smaller cookies and up to 14 minutes for larger ones. Cook completely on rack.

See my instagram video for baking, decorating and assembling tips.

Holiday Sugar Cookie House | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

Decorate with Royal icing, sprinkles or other decorations. Let stand until icing sets.

Royal Icing:

3 1/4 cups powdered sugar, sifted

2 large egg whites

1 teaspoon lemon juice, strained

Using electric mixer, beat 3 1/4 cups powdered sugar, egg whites and lemon juice until thick and shiny, adding more powdered sugar by the tablespoon if it is too thin to spread, about 3 minutes. Cover with wet towel until ready to use.

Fill a parchment pastry bag with about 3 tablespoons of the royal icing. The consistency should be soft enough to pipe but firm enough to hold its shape, like soft mashed potatoes. Cut a very small hole at the tip of the bag and draw an outline around the cookie. If you are going to be flooding the center of the cookie with icing than double up the outline.

You can also separate the icing into little bowls and add coloring. Be sure to keep the icing covered at all times because it is meant to dry out and will end up with a crust if exposed to air.

Here are some tips for making cookies that are a little less over-the-top, but equally as fun and tasty:

docorating christmas cookies

Once all of your cookies have been outlined then you will want to thin out a portion of your icing in order to flood the center. It should be the consistency of molasses. Fill another parchment pastry bag about 1/4 of the way full. Carefully flood the area between your outline. Go slowly so as not to go over the lines you’ve drawn.

docorating christmas cookies

docorating christmas cookies

docorating christmas cookies

Once the you’ve flooded the center of the cookie with the icing it will be shiny and wet, you can put decorations on the icing and they will stick. You can also let the icing dry and it will lose its shine but you can then pipe more decor over the icing. (The cookies below: the cookie in the foreground is wet and the one in the back is dry)

docorating christmas cookies

Here are the cookies as I was working on them.

Holiday Sugar Cookies | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

Holiday Sugar Cookies | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

These small photos are from the original post in 2007, they aren’t very good, but they represent a sweet memory, so I am keeping them in the updated post.

Here is the house that inspired the cookie version:

Holiday Sugar Cookie House | ZoeBakes photo by Zoë François

 

22 thoughts to “Holiday Sugar Cookies”

  1. hi zoe –
    happy holidays!!
    just checking that i’m not missing any info. about my chocolate chip cookie dilemma…
    have you posted a response somewhere that i haven’t located – or is it still coming in the future?
    cheers!
    these cookies look gorgeous!
    tracy
    p.s. i’m on my 4th ‘bucket of bread’ since christmas!!(and keep ordering more copies of your book to give to friends!
    everyone thinks i’m an AMAZING bread baker!!and that your’s is an AMAZING book!
    THANK YOU THANK YOU!!

  2. Hi Tracy,

    I have the bag of Nestle chips on my counter just waiting for the butter to soften! I’ll write a post in the next couple of days! Thanks for checking.

    I’m so thrilled you are baking so much bread.

    Happy New Year!!! Zoë

  3. these look great! I owe the neighbors some cookie. They have a peanut-allergic kid, which means i can’t use commercial chocolate chips, so these will fill the bill.

  4. Hi Patricia,

    Great idea for your neighbor! Just make sure you always read the label on the ingredients just to make sure they don’t warn of the equipment being used for other nut production. I’m always surprised what shares machines with nuts!

    Thanks! Zoë

  5. I really love this idea, dears. My husband and I would love to do this. My name is Hans. I really feel that I need more information so my significant other and I may produce our own version. Thanks for the origianal idea, but please send me more info on how to make it. Thanks, hun and happy holidays,

    Hans.

  6. I was wondering about the royal icing and how exactly to thin it for the smooth look you show? what do I use to then it? water? and how much?

  7. Hi Heidi,

    You can use water or even lemon juice, if it goes with the flavor of your cookie. Just add a drop at a time until you have the consistency of molasses.

    Enjoy and happy holidays!

    Zoë

  8. We made these…Wonderful cookies. Easy recipe, easy dough to work with, EXCELLENT results. We even rolled a bunch up in balls and pressed big sprinkles in them. Yum. Thanks! Merry, Merry!

  9. I Zoe
    Thank you for all those lovely recipies. You are an inpiration. I spend great time cooking with the kids and surprise all family in Christmas eve.
    Cristina
    Portugal

  10. Zoe, Your decorating ideas are terrific. Love the piping first, so the ‘filler’ doesn’t run wild! And the Royal Frosting is one of my faves for quick drying. But…

    Question: What do you suggest for quick drying for someone highly allergic to egg white?

    Thanks!

    Joanne

  11. I’ve always wanted to try making these cookies. It looks wonderful…now I have a reason to. Thanks for sharing it to us avid bakers!

    Tina
    Manila< Philippines

  12. I made them today and they were quite good although really small cookies need 5-6 min top 😛 The dough was easily used and the icing a success.

    Tip i made two dozens of 3cm xmas trees with green royal icing and then spread some colourful sprinkles on top (like this but only smaller: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_gXpjXQMeWPA/TPURSvujGpI/AAAAAAAABRs/SVTpC3-4yes/s640/Christmas_tree_cookies_with_icing_and_sprinkles.jpg) they turned out amazing!!!! ps try them with red royal icing as well 🙂

    1. Hi Ric,

      Yes, freeze the cookies and then ice them, if time is permitting. The icing may get damaged if you freeze and stack the cookies. Be sure to leave the cookies wrapped as they are defrosting.

      Cheers, Zoe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *