Butterscotch Pot de Crème (and Pumpkin Version for Fall)

Butterscotch Pot de Crème | Photo by Zoë François

I developed this butterscotch pot de crème recipe for Tilia‘s dessert menu. Steven Brown, the chef/owner wanted a turbo charged version of the butterscotch pudding from his childhood. We went with a Pot de crème, which is essentially as decadent as creme brulee, without the crack of caramel resting on top. The texture is like silk and the taste is lightly sweet, with just a slight bitter edge from the burnt sugar in the butterscotch. Cooking the butter and brown sugar together until it is smokin’ hot (and I do mean smoking) is the key to the flavor. If you don’t bring them to the brink of burning the pudding will be way too sweet for my taste. The crème fraîche (young sour cream) is unsweetened and the perfect balance for the pudding. If you don’t happen to live near Linden Hills (a small village of a neighborhood in Minneapolis), where you can order this at Tilia, you can now make it at home.

You can watch me make this Buttercotch Pot de Crème on my instagram stories.

Butterscotch Pot de Crème | Photo by Zoë François

Tilia’s Butterscotch Pot de Crème

makes about twelve 2 1/2-ounce servings

4 tablespoons unsalted butter

1 cup brown sugar, well packed

4 cups heavy cream

1 vanilla bean, scraped

1/2 teaspoon salt

8 large egg yolks

Crème fraiche:

2 cups heavy cream

1/4 cup buttermilk

Stir the buttermilk into the cream and let sit at room temperature for 8 hours or until thick. Refrigerate. Can be made a few days ahead.

To make the Butterscotch (watch my video of making this on instagram):

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

In a medium sized heavy-bottomed sauce pot, cook the butter and brown sugar together over medium heat.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Stir with a wooden spoon or carefully whisk (be sure to use the right kind of whisk (Egg Whisk) or the sugar will get caught in the wires). The sugar and butter will separate at first, but as the sugar melts it will become easier to blend them together.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Cook and stir until the sugar melts and the butter/sugar mixture just starts to brown, it will start to smoke slightly as well.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Slowly add the cream, one cup at a time.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

It will sputter and sieze up as you add the cold cream. Cook the butterscotch until the seized sugar dissolves again. Add the rest of the cream, vanilla bean and salt.

To make the custard:

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

In a bowl, whisk together the egg yolks. Slowly add some of the hot butterscotch-cream to the yolks as you whisk them. You are just adding enough of the warm cream to warm the yolks slightly.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Once the yolks are warm to the touch, pour the yolks back into the pot of hot butterscotch-cream and gently whisk.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Strain the mixture. (I made a giant batch, that is why I have so many vanilla beans in this shot)

To bake the custard: Preheat the oven to 325°F.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

Divide the custard into the eight 4-ounce ramekins. Place them in a water batch and tent with foil. It is important that the water in the pan is hot and comes half way up the side of the ramekins, so that it will reach oven temperature quickly. Using cool water will prevent them from baking evenly.

Bake for 25 to 40 minutes. This will depend on the temperature of the mixture when you put it in the oven. Best to check them after 25 minutes and gauge how much longer they need. Unlike a cake, you can open the oven and check them as often as you like without hurting them. The best way to check if they are done is to gently tap the side of each ramekin. If the custard ripples like water, it needs to bake longer. If it moves like set jell-o, then it is done. Be careful not to over bake them or they will be grainy and “eggy.”

Remove the pan from the oven and allow the custards to cool in the water bath. Once they have reached room temperature, you can remove them from the bath, cover them and refrigerate for at least an hour, but they can be made a few days in advance.

How to make Butterscotch Pot de Crème

To serve the butterscotch pot de crème: Spread a thin layer of unsweetened crème fraîche over the top of the custard.

I like the contrast of the unsweetened crème fraiche and the sweet pudding, but you can add a touch of sugar if it is too stark for your taste. Or serve it with nothing at all.

Beautiful white and blue mugs for Butterscotch Pot de Crème | Photo by Zoë François

Butterscotch Pot de Crème | Photo by Zoë François

*For a pumpkin version of this just substitute one cup of the heavy cream with 1 1/4 cups pumpkin puree and add 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice. Add the pumpkin and spice after you have added all the yolks and cream to the mixture.